MLAEliza:
This is a huge issue for my organization as well. I am currently manually editing their expiration date when I do the accounting reconciliation, but that is an extra step and only works since I am the whole staff. I will try the process above, but having a built in process would be better.
HI,
I just read your posting of 2011/02/04. You have the same problem as we have. I was in the process of implementing the work around mentioned in this conversation, but I had a question and called WA. They told me that earlier this year, they had fixed the problem.
I had no idea!
Anyway, I was told it is all based on being LAPSED. If a member is lapsed, and then renews online, the renewal effective date will be the day they PAY. For example, if a member lasped in July 2010, but renewed online and paid with paypal in Sep 2011, then the membership would run Sep 2011 to Sep 2012. If they pay with cheque or cash, the period will start the day the administrator processes the payment.
He also told me the date on the renew button will be wrong for long lapsed members, but it doesn't matter since the system doesn't use it. (I think it is confusing with the wrong date, so I have changed it so that the button just says "Renew".)
I wish I had known earlier; hope this helps you.
GEM